The Cooleys, Coolleys, and Coles

(Three genetically unrelated groups)
Stokes County NC Cooleys

(Eleven Cooleys tested with near matches.)
Fayette County PA Coolleys

(Two Cooleys tested with exact matches to 37 markers.)
New York Dutch Coles*

(Eight near-matching Cool/Cole testers.)
*Cool is pronounced "Cole" by the Dutch.
Barent Cool
(1610-1684+)1
m Marrtje de Graeuw
Leendert Cool
(1647-1735)
m Marretje Della Cornelis
Leendert Cool
(bapt 1675-)
m Annetje Decker
Johannes Cool
(bapt 1679-)
m Neeltje Roosa
Willem L. Cool
(1689-)2
m Catrinjen du Bois
Leendert Cool
(bapt 1700-)
m Sara Van Garden
Cornelis Cool
(bapt 1715-)3
m1 Sara Westval
m2 Claesje Jongbloet
Johannes Cool
(1714-)
m Pierternella van Auken
John Cooley
(c1740-1811)4

Said by Pat Walker to have been Johannes Cool-1.
William Coolley (-1817)5
"of Irish extraction."

married Elizabeth Firmin


Johannes Cool-1
(bapt 1741-)6

By 1982, Pat Walker decided that this, the son of the above couple, was John, who he said married Elizabeth Fermin.


Only known child by Sara Westval:

Johannes Cool-2
(bapt 1740-)7

This is the man Lura Hamil said married first Annetje Decker and married second Elizabeth Firmin (who really married William Cooley, three columns to the left) and was the progenitor of the Fayette county PA Cooleys. Pat Walker bought the Cooley/Firmin marriage and by 1980 made Johannes Cool (as John Cooley, first column) the founder of the Stokes county NC Cooleys (which is decidedly not true). DNA test results, not to mention the total lack of supporting genealogical documentation, disprove these relationships.


Two sons by Cornelis's marriage to Claesje:

Jacob Cole (c1748-)8

Cornelis Westbroeck
Cole
(c1750-)9
William Cole
(1756-)
m Sara Wells
Edward Cooley
(1763-1822)
John Andrew Coolley Sr
(1767-1847)

Said by Hamil to have been son of Johannes Cool-2.
Frederick Cooley
(1781-1845)
Thomas J. Cole
(1790-1866)
John Cooley
(1789-1866)
Samuel Means Coolley
(1800-1847)
John Cooley
(1822-1899)
Benjamin H. Cole
(1816-1898)
David Cooley
(1815-1865)
Thomas Jefferson Cooley
(1831-c1897)
Arthur H. Cooley
(1849-1909)
George N. Cole
(1851-1933)
Greenbury Cooley
(1844-1899)
William Franklin Cooley
(1868-1897)
Frank L. Cooley
(1875-1920)
Electus S. Cole
(1878-)
Joseph William Cooley
(1867-1947)
Franklin Arthur Cooley
(1893-1963)
Frank Hudson Cooley
(1915-1975)
Kenneth H. Cole
(1904-1981)
McCabe Cooley
(1899-1958)
The author's grandfather
FTDNA kit #57597
Franklin Arthur Cooley
(1926-2007)
Father of tester
FTDNA kit #173367
Frank Cooley
living
FTDNA kit #167462
Stewart H. Cole,
Bromme Cole's grandfather
Y-Search NA29T

1For details of descent, see Richard H. Benson, The Barent Jacobsen Cool Family (Boston: Newbury Street Press, 2001).

2Descent from Willem L. Cool to Stewart H. Cole taken from "Du Bois, Louis - Descendant Chart," The Order of the Crown of Charlemagne in the United States of America, http://www.charlemagne.org/ui115.htm.

3Baptismal and Marriage Registers of the Old Dutch Church of Kingston, Ulster County, New York, 1660-1809. Cornelis Cool was baptized 31 July 1715. Parents: Johannes Cool, Neeltjen Roos; Witnesses: Cornelis Cool, Alida Naks.

4John last appears in the public record in 1811. That same year, three sons moved to Missouri, one son to Indiana, and another son (by 1812) to Tennessee.

5John M. Gresham, editor, Biographical and Portrait Cyclopedia of Fayette County, Pennsylvania (Chicago: John M. Gresham & Co., 1889), 421. A copy of the sketch, transcribed by Marta Burns, is online at http://ancestraldata.com/ahnentafel/256/elizabethfirmin.html. Names wife Elizabeth Firmin. The 1810 census of Fayette County, PA enumerates William and wife. The family bible of Jonathan Coolley provides death dates for William, Elizabeth, and Jonathan's daughter, Elizabeth Firmin Coolley.

6"Church Register of the Walpeck Congregation," Minisink Valley Reformed Dutch Church Records, ed. Royden Woodward Vosburgh, Collections of the New York Genealogical and Biographical Society 5 (New York: Printed for the Society, 1913), 1. Johannes Cool was baptized on 31 May 1741. Parents: Leanard Cool and Sara van Garden; Witnesses Johannes Rosenkrantz, Catherine Rosenkrantz.

7Records of Baptisms of the Reformed Church at Machackemeck (Deerpark), Orange County New York, 1716-1742. Johannes Cool was baptized on 17 June 1740. Parents: Cornelis Cool, Sara Westval; Witnesses: Johannes Westval and Sara Cool.

8Records of Baptisms of the Reformed Church at Machackemeck (Deerpark), Orange County New York, 1747-1749. Jacob Cole was baptized 27 Nov 1748. Parents: Cornelis Cole, Claesje Jongbloet; Witnesses: Jacob Van Etten and wife, Antje Westbroeck.

9Records of Baptisms of the Reformed Church at Machackemeck (Deerpark), Orange County New York, 1749-1750. Cornelis Westbroeck Cole was baptized 4 Mar 1750. Parents: Cornelis Cole, Claesje Jongbloet; Witnesses: Cornelis Westbroeck, Antje Rosa, his wife.